A Premises Liability Case: Shopper Trips and Falls over Pallet
Case Summary: A woman tripped and fell inside a big box store after removing a case of bottled water from a pallet load. Her foot was entangled in the stretch wrap that had been left around the bottom of the pallet load. The case of bottled water that she had removed fell onto her leg. The accident, which was captured on store surveillance, resulted in a broken ankle and fractured knee cap.
Expert Analysis: The pallet load consisted of 48 cases, arranged in six tiers. The total weight of the pallet load was 2,275 lbs. Restraining a load of that weight and size through transportation, storage, and handling requires stretch wrap that is thick and durable. When the pallet load becomes a floor display, however, the stretch wrap will have served its purpose and should be removed. Stretch wrap left around the bottom of a pallet load of bottled water is a foreseeable tripping hazard, due not only to its placement, but also due to its resistance to tearing.
Industry standards and best practices call for removing stretch wrap from a floor display. The deposed store manager testified that it is the store’s policy to remove the stretch wrap after pallet loads are taken to the floor. Once removed, the stretch wrap is taken to a compactor.
The 40-count case of bottled water that Plaintiff had lifted weighed 44 lbs. A falling case, therefore, has sufficient weight and momentum to injure someone. Cases must be taken from the top tier of the pallet load, sometimes requiring a shopper to reach and grab, for which they would need secure footing. Stretch wrap left around the bottom of a pallet load of bottled water is a trip-and-fall hazard in and of itself, but becomes more hazardous if the victim is holding a case of water.
The defendant store had a duty of care to maintain safe premises. That duty of care was breached when stretch wrap was left around the bottom of the subject pallet load, resulting in a foreseeable trip-and-fall hazard. The hazard played out as the direct and proximate cause of Plaintiff’s accident and injuries.
Result: The case went to trial. Verdict for Plaintiff.
Sterling Anthony, B.S., MBA, CPP
Product Packaging Expert
View all articles by Sterling Anthony, B.S., MBA, CPP